Protesters Successfully Challenge Procurement Revealing Multiple Errors in Agency’s Evaluation; GAO B-414844, ENSCO Inc., PAE National Security Solutions LLC

Protest challenging the agency’s evaluation and best value determination is sustained, where the agency applied an unstated evaluation criterion when assigning a significant weakness in relation to the protesters’ proposed personnel, unreasonably concluded that the awardee satisfied the solicitation’s experience and training requirements, unreasonably allowed the awardee to submit employee resumes that exceeded the stated page limitation, and performed an unreasonable cost realism analysis.